Bars

Sourmugs Tavern

4.6 126 reviews 3:00 PM - 12:00 AM 101 N Miami St, West Milton, OH 45383, United States

Discover this place

Sourmugs Tavern, located at 101 N Miami St, West Milton, OH, embodies a vibrant blend of casual charm and spirited fun. This welcoming bar offers a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering wings, gourmet pizza, and unique appetizers like deep-fried pickles and mushroom spears. Known for its excellent service, Sourmugs Tavern caters to all, providing wheelchair-accessible facilities, a kids’ menu, and options for dining in or takeaway. With a fantastic selection of beers and cocktails, along with engaging quiz nights and bar games, it creates a cozy atmosphere perfect for groups or solo diners. Whether you're catching the game or enjoying a night out, Sourmugs Tavern is sure to delight.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Bar games
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Live music
Live performances
Sports
Trivia night

Popular for

Solo dining

Dining options

Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Sourmugs Tavern before visiting.

Reviews for Sourmugs Tavern

4.6

126 reviews

100%

14%

Review highlights

Based on 126 reviews

Sourmugs Tavern in West Milton is widely praised for its flavorful and diverse menu, with standout items including wings, fried mushrooms, pizza, and unique sauces that enhance the dining experience. Guests frequently comment on the consistently high food quality and appreciate the variety of comfort food options. The service is often highlighted as friendly and attentive, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere, though some note occasional wait times during busy periods. While the bar’s ambiance may not appeal to everyone, many choose takeaway and still enjoy the food’s excellence. Overall, Sourmugs Tavern is regarded as a local gem offering satisfying meals and reliable service in a casual setting.

John Wallace

Apr 06, 2025

A great place for a family to come and eat great food. Wings are amazing. Pizza is great too. Fried pickles are exceptional! Fried mushrooms too. Never had anything bad. Service is always very friendly. Sometimes they are busy so it can take a while, but that's okay because the vibes are good. Highly recommend.

Sherri Fischer

Mar 22, 2025

Always great food. Server is amazing. If she were ever to leave, we would be devastated. Makes you feel like you are the only customer in a room packed full of other patrons. And the memory of an elephant! We always get the fried mushrooms. They have changed in size, but still the same light batter and quite tasty. I decided on the turkey Ruben this time and was not disappointed. My husband, however, got the Italian sub and didn't care for the overpowering (his words) rosemary flavor. Take it for what it's worth...it was an Italian sub. He did like the Long Island Iced Tea that our server made. And he has very high standards when it comes to those. As always, an enjoyable visit to Sourmugs. For those who have not visited, it is a one level building, no stairs, entrance in front, but most enter from side entrance. Parking on street or lot behind. They get crowded so time your visit appropriately. Enjoy!

Russell Landwehr

Mar 21, 2025

I've been here quite a few times.The food has NEVER disappointed!I've always been completely satisfied with my meal, AND the hardworking staff.Tonight I had a Ruben pizza with extra cheese.Y'all gotta try it!

Loraine Wyatt

Feb 17, 2025

Not into dark bars...so we carry outBut their food is awesome! Yummy chicken and their Dad's sauce is sooo good with ranch salads.. fries are not always hot.. but again.. is great

CAM

Feb 01, 2025

This is West Milton's best kept secret. You may have to wait for a beer, but the service is top notch. The food is amazing. I almost want to not review so I can keep this place a secret. My favorite menu items: portobello mushrooms, chicken chunks, and pizza. The side mac and cheese is a meal in itself. I wish I would have found this place sooner.

Peyton Leet

Jan 20, 2025

Really great place. Service is great, and the food is amazing. The boneless wings in the dads sauce is super high quality and so is the pizza. My only regret is not checking it out sooner.

Z F

Jan 09, 2025

Highly recommend! Went on Saturday afternoon, couldn't have had better service. The bartender recognized we were new to the place was helpful with our wing sauces and beet choices. Go with the Daddy sauce. We got wings and a deluxe pizza. Get both! We'll definitely be back!

firedude915

Dec 31, 2024

Some of the items on the menu are hit or miss. But, about 80% of the time it is on point. Pizza is pretty good. One of the 2 pizza places in town that has good pizza.